Are Abortifacients Abortifacient?

Here is an atrocious, obviously biased, and above all badly written piece of dreck from the New York Times.  You should all read it, because, if you can get through the gentle assassination of the English language in the service of Queen Cecile I, it brings up the most important development in pro-life science that pro-lifers aren’t talking about:

Adding to their passionate opposition to the rule that employees of religiously affiliated institutions must receive insurance coverage for birth control, Roman Catholic bishops and some evangelical groups have asserted that it also requires coverage of some forms of abortion.

They contend that methods of contraception including morning-after pills and IUDs can be considered “abortifacients” because, these advocates say, they can act to prevent pregnancy after a man’s sperm has fertilized a woman’s egg.

“We object to the use of drugs and procedures used to take the lives of unborn children,” the Rev. Dr. Matthew C. Harrison, president of the Lutheran Church — Missouri Synod, said Thursday at a hearing of the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform.

Their reasoning is that life begins the moment an egg is fertilized, and that if a contraceptive has the potential to prevent the implantation of a fertilized egg in the uterus, it is aborting a life.

To which any sane person with even a tenuous hold on common English language, science, or indeed everyday reality remarks, “Duh.”  Moving right along:

Several scientists and doctors said in interviews that this view [may] not reflect the way the birth control methods actually work. “There’s so much evidence for how these things work prior to fertilization,” said Diana L. Blithe, director of contraceptive development for the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development. “And there’s no evidence that they work beyond fertilization.”

She and other experts said these methods are so effective in preventing fertilization that the chance of an egg and sperm uniting is slim… While several medical Web sites, including some from government agencies, raise the possibility that the morning-after pill could affect implantation, Dr. Blithe and others said it had not been scientifically verified that the drugs work that way.

One morning-after pill, Plan B, contains a synthetic progesterone that blocks ovulation, said Dr. Anita Nelson, a professor of obstetrics and gynecology at the David Geffen School of Medicine at the University of California, Los Angeles. Recent studies have indicated that women who take Plan B after ovulation have a normal chance of becoming pregnant, [suggesting] that Plan B does not prevent their fertilized eggs from implanting, Dr. Nelson said…

[However, i]f fertilization [should] occur, the embryo runs a high risk of not implanting [because of the intervention of the high-dose hormones used in contraception, resulting in embryonic death].

[Ed. Note: I have reluctantly edited the source material in some places where it related actual, objectively verifiable falsehoods.  My changes are in brackets.  The Times also insists on that perpetuating that degenerate figment of poor writing, the "fertilized egg," which, as all clear-minded persons can readily remind you, is an oxymoron.  There are other places in the article where terrible abuses of language and fact occur, but I do not need to quote them, thank God.]

I hate this article, as I believe I have already made clear.  But the basic point is important, and, despite dramatically exaggerating the science so as to more easily make fun of those weird religionists with their crazy science beliefs, the Times still manages to include the emerging scientific consensus underneath all the nonsense: abortifacients might not be abortifacient.

I learned this several years ago, when I helped with a major revision to the Wikipedia article on emergency contraception.  My role in the revision was to delve into the very latest and best research on how EC actually worked, especially whether it was an abortifacient.  Looking back, it seems that the majority of my work is still in place, essentially unchanged.  So go take a look!

Quick history: in the 1970s, science realized that contraceptive pills were thinning the uterine walls to the point where implantation of a living human embryo would be impossible, leading directly to the death of the child in an abortion.  So, if any sperms and eggs made it past the standard contraceptive defenses (ovulatory suppression, spermicide) and managed to meet up in the fallopian tubes and made a baby, that baby would basically be refused admission to the uterine lining by the contraceptive bouncer and evicted from the body — killed.  Since we know that combined oral contraceptive pill (COCP) users frequently end up having babies anyway, it seemed obvious that some babies were getting created, and surely some percentage of them were being killed off at the uterine wall.  This was a very strong hypothesis, and everyone believed it.  Justice John Paul Stevens cited it prominently in his pro-abortion opinion in Webster v. Reproductive Health Services of Missouri.   Frankly, it was good science, and it became a major ethical dilemma for pro-lifers: most of us did not want to be seen as trying to outlaw contraceptives, because we’d look like insane radicals.  At the same time, if contraceptives were actually abortion drugs, obviously we couldn’t stay quiet about them!

The Times, of course, drops all this down the memory hole.  But it’s the Times.  What do you expect?  Reporting?

Good hypothesis though it was, it had yet to be tested, and experimentation is a must in good natural science.  So we started experimenting.

Twenty years later, we have nothing to show for it.  There is absolutely no evidence, in practice, that contraceptive drugs actually kill babies.  Indeed, there’s some positive evidence that they do not kill babies.  (You can go to my Wikipedia article for the citations if you like.)  There continues to be some good reasons to believe that the IUD is abortifacient, but your basic everyday contraceptive pills, and even Plan B, very well might not be.  If we can ever prove this for sure, it would be unalloyed good news for the pro-life movement, above all because it means American moms aren’t unknowingly wiping out their own ten-child families every day.  This would also make it approximately one BLILLION [stet] times easier to pass effective pro-life legal measures, such as the Personhood Mississippi initiative that was brought down in November over precisely these kinds of concerns (also Planned Parenthood’s lies). Pro-lifers should pay attention to this, should catch up on the science, and present their case accordingly.

The fact is, unfortunately, there still isn’t any clarity on the science here, and there’s unlikely to be any clarity for a long time.  Until we do have a verdict one way or the other, it would be ethically negligent (gravely so) to employ contraceptive methods, especially Plan B or the copper-based IUD, which have a modest likelihood of occasionally killing a human being.  But that’s the case we need to start articulating.  We must stop statically repeating thirty-year-old hypotheses as if they are simply canonical fact.

We can also sleep with much lighter hearts, knowing there’s a fairly good chance that the abortion crisis is not quite so bad as we have long imagined.

This entry was posted in Abolitionism, Mere Opinion. Bookmark the permalink.

212 Responses to Are Abortifacients Abortifacient?

  1. Pingback: Why I Support the Minnesota Marriage Amendment » De Civitate

  2. Pingback: scam web host

  3. Pingback: axine actional brilliancy

  4. Pingback: auto rental costa rica

  5. Pingback: Clarence

  6. Pingback: Kliknij

  7. Pingback: national moving

  8. Pingback: lindsay lohan cirugia

  9. Pingback: home business ideas

  10. Pingback: Zobacz teraz

  11. Pingback: buy generic viagra online india

  12. Pingback: Building a Mobile App

  13. Pingback: increase online sales

  14. Pingback: กระดาษ

  15. Pingback: anonymous

  16. Pingback: Buy Idol Lash

  17. Pingback: customized license plate frame

  18. Pingback: usb serial hub

  19. Pingback: yamaha ef3000iseb generator

  20. Pingback: pdr training

  21. Pingback: paintless dent repair training

  22. Pingback: denver auto accident attorney

  23. Pingback: continue reading this..

  24. Pingback: belly dance san diego

  25. Pingback: Spiritual Coach

  26. Pingback: กระดาษอาร์ต

  27. Pingback: small business

  28. Pingback: lawn edgings

  29. Pingback: secured loans UK

  30. Pingback: กระดาษปอนด์

  31. Pingback: กระดาษถนอมสายตา

  32. Pingback: pure garcinia cambogia extract

  33. Pingback: Michael Jackson Cirugia Estetica

  34. Pingback: website

  35. Pingback: where buy garcinia cambogia

  36. Pingback: garcinia cambogia weight loss

  37. Pingback: miracle garcinia cambogia

  38. Pingback: garcinia cambogia extract

  39. Pingback: garcinia cambogia side effects

  40. Pingback: garcinia cambogia reviews

  41. Pingback: กระดาษอาร์ตการ์ด

  42. Pingback:

  43. Pingback:

  44. Pingback: Lake Orion Fitness Center

  45. Pingback: tactical scopes review

  46. Pingback: full report

  47. Pingback: John Agnello 20th century art

  48. Pingback: animated video

  49. Pingback: Arnold

  50. Pingback: pain shoulder

  51. Pingback:

  52. Pingback: weight loss motivation

  53. Pingback:

  54. Pingback: click this link

  55. Pingback:

  56. Pingback: abogado costa del sol

  57. Pingback: 海外房产

  58. Pingback: paintless dent removal training for dent repair

  59. Pingback: how to text girls you like

  60. Pingback: tree removal alpharetta

  61. Pingback: more info

  62. Pingback: online paid surveys

  63. Pingback: paintless dent repair training

  64. Pingback: miranda kerr & orlando bloom

  65. Pingback: tree removal alpharetta

  66. Pingback: Tacoma chiropractic center

  67. Pingback: click here

  68. Pingback: dent removal training

  69. Pingback: pdr training for dent repair

  70. Pingback: paintless dent removal school course training

  71. Pingback: paintless dent repair training craigslist

  72. Pingback: pdr training

  73. Pingback: paintless dent removal by the patch

  74. Pingback: go to this web-site

  75. Pingback: paintless dent removal school

  76. Pingback: Continue Reading

  77. Pingback: wedding photographers

  78. Pingback: sai

  79. Pingback: sacramento in home care elderly

  80. Pingback: lady gaga pictures

  81. Pingback: tree cutting atlanta

  82. Pingback: online

  83. Pingback: nicki minaj without makeup 2013

  84. Pingback: youtube

  85. Pingback: Tacoma family chiropractic

  86. Pingback: DIN Rail Power Supplies - 24V DIN-Rail mounted switching power supplies

  87. Pingback: tarot barato

  88. Pingback: paintless dent repair tools

  89. Pingback: giochi slot gratis

  90. Pingback: note pads personalized

  91. Pingback: ken tevis

  92. Pingback: life cover

  93. Pingback: www slot gratis

  94. Pingback: Medico gijon

  95. Pingback: European Roulette Free

  96. Pingback: online roulette game for fun

  97. Pingback: online roulette 50statescasino

  98. Pingback: Restaurante Gijon

  99. Pingback: hair extensions

  100. Pingback: free online astrology reading

  101. Pingback: batangas resorts

  102. Pingback: how to get a girl to like you

  103. Pingback: giochi slot gratis 3d

  104. Pingback: visitare questo sito

  105. Pingback: giochi casino slot gratis

  106. Pingback: giochi online slot gratis

  107. Pingback: online psychic

  108. Pingback: Joshua Jacobi

  109. Pingback: paintless dent repair training

  110. Pingback: .

  111. Pingback: Acai Berry Weight Loss

  112. Pingback: kite

  113. Pingback: paintless dent repair training

  114. Pingback: this link

  115. Pingback: Babelfish

  116. Pingback: cirugia esteticas plastica

  117. Pingback: tworzenie stron warszawa -

  118. Pingback:

  119. Pingback: textile printing

  120. Pingback: truth about abs system free download

  121. Pingback: click here

  122. Pingback: co to jest aspartam

  123. Pingback:

  124. Pingback: Orlando Attorney

  125. Pingback: slot machine gratis gallina uova d'oro

  126. Pingback: video slot gratis

  127. Pingback: shriram transport finance shares

  128. Pingback: how to start a business

  129. Pingback: felix opinie

  130. Pingback: european roulette online usa

  131. Pingback: fare clic

  132. Pingback: paintless dent repair training craigslist

  133. Pingback: volvo v40

  134. Pingback:

  135. Pingback:

  136. Pingback: giochi slot machine gratis gallina dalle uova doro

  137. Pingback: celebrity plastic surgery

  138. Pingback: celebrities that look alike

  139. Pingback: prestamos rapidos

  140. Pingback: working from home

  141. Pingback: aspartam produkty

  142. Pingback: how to conceive a girl calendar

  143. Pingback: Odkryj proste grillowanie

  144. Pingback: training paintless dent repair

  145. Pingback: paintless dent repair training

  146. Pingback: click here

  147. Pingback:

  148. Pingback: kremy eucerin opinie

  149. Pingback: Joshua Jacobi the cheater

  150. Pingback: how to purify water

  151. Pingback: 100 approval payday loans

  152. Pingback: check here

  153. Pingback: plantacja lawendy

  154. Pingback: jazda konna

  155. Pingback: autoversicherung

  156. Pingback: kfz versicherungsvergleich

  157. Pingback: berufsunfähigkeitsversicherung

  158. Pingback: make money from home

  159. Pingback: berufsunfähigkeitsversicherung

  160. Pingback: Blog lesen

  161. Pingback: how to win the lottery book utah lottery

  162. Pingback: how to win the lottery free visit the next web page

  163. Pingback: strompreis

  164. Pingback: stromanbieter vergleich

  165. Pingback: unfallversicherung

  166. Pingback: tagesgeldkonto

  167. Pingback:

  168. Pingback: shoulder impingement

  169. Pingback: you can try this out

  170. Pingback: paris hilton surgery

  171. Pingback: Zalando Gutschein

  172. Pingback: see here

  173. Pingback: torn shoulder ligament

  174. Pingback: Website

  175. Pingback: new business ideas

  176. Pingback: ccna training

  177. Pingback: bruce jenner plastic surgery

  178. Pingback: Facebook Like Button

  179. Pingback: online casino

  180. Pingback: hoodia weight loss

  181. Pingback: people finder

  182. Pingback: empower network scam

  183. Pingback: Samsung Galaxy S3

  184. Pingback: ageless male reviews

  185. Pingback: jnciouencuhepuvb9ehn9f938un

  186. Pingback:

  187. Pingback: kris jenner surgery

  188. Pingback: mens health

  189. Pingback: jimmy rose

  190. Pingback: casino online con bonus gratis senza deposito

  191. Pingback: milton keynes driving lesson

  192. Pingback: louis vuitton outlet

  193. Pingback: http://rudyserra

  194. Pingback: michael kors bags

  195. Pingback: louboutin sale

  196. Pingback: nike air max

  197. Pingback: louis vuitton online outlet

  198. Pingback: cheap jordans for sale

  199. Pingback: cheap jordans shoes

  200. Pingback: louis vuitton bags sale

  201. Pingback: coach outlet store online

  202. Pingback: cheap christian louboutin outlet

  203. Pingback: michael kors handbags outlet

  204. Pingback: louis vuitton online outlet

  205. Pingback: louis vuitton purses

  206. Pingback: rabaty

  207. Pingback: generic keyword list

  208. Pingback: rabaty

  209. Pingback: rabaty

  210. Pingback: seo company

  211. Pingback: seo

  212. Pingback: gthcezty